Solidarity Against SEZs - Demand for PEZs


amka naka SEZ, amka zai PEZ

(we do not want SEZ, we want PEZ)

PEZ: rice gruel (in Konkani) PEZ= Peoples' Economic Zones


Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Silence protest to get MLAs to speak





Over 80 activists of the SEZ Virodhi Manch (SVM) stood in silent protest at the approach road of the Mandovi Bridge. The silent protest sought to draw the attention of the MLAs to walk the talk during the Assembly sessions. Placards, posters and banners were held by the protestors.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

SEZ: Unending saga

Editorial in today's oHeraldo
SEZ: Unending saga

It is the government’s continued inaction on the issue of the Special Economic Zones (SEZs) that is responsible for incidents like the one on Tuesday, when activists of the SEZ Virodhi Manch (SVM) and the Goa Bachao Abhiyan (GBA) barged into the site of the Raheja SEZ at Verna on learning that work had recommenced, forcibly stopped it, and caused the labourers at the site to flee. This would not at all have been necessary, had the government systematically probed into the SEZ mess and proceeded against the fraudsters.

In fact, it is the government’s reticence in the matter that has emboldened the Union Commerce Ministry, which seems to be unequivocally on the side of the SEZ promoters, to make outrageous and incorrect statements in the matter, and place unreasonable demands on the Goa government.

The fact is that all the SEZs have applied for land that is hugely over their real requirements. For example, why does a company that sets up its BPO units in one or two buildings in Mumbai, want 4 lakh square metres for similar units in Goa? Then, there are huge irregularities in the land allotments. These are well documented by the anti-SEZ activists through the Right to Information (RTI). They have been widely publicised through the media, both print and electronic, and never been adequately challenged, either by the SEZ promoters, the government or the Goa Industrial Development Corporation (IDC).

Simply setting up an inquiry headed by a retired High Court judge into these irregularities would have given the government all the ammunition it needed to conclusively end the controversy and justifiably cancel the land allotment. But it has resolutely refused to do so.

Why? Is it because too many functionaries belonging to the ruling party would get implicated in the resulting scam? Is it because a number of those that were willing accomplices in this massive fraud continue to occupy very high positions?

Whatever the reason, the refusal of the government is very intriguing. To start with, though it asserts that SEZs will never be allowed, the government is yet to officially denotify its SEZ policy. After the SEZ promoters approached the High Court, it withdrew the ‘Stop Work’ order it had issued on 31 December. It simultaneously cancelled the land allotments. However, these were cancelled by the IDC, but this was on the basis that SEZs were ‘against’ government policy, not because of any irregularities in allotment. Considering that the official SEZ policy is still in force, this cancellation is unlikely to survive a court challenge, just like the earlier ‘Stop Work’ order.

In the meanwhile, the Union Commerce Ministry is keeping up the pressure. It first said it had no power to denotify the notified SEZs. This is bunk. A plain perusal of the General Clauses Act will show that the power to notify embodies the power to denotify, and all that is required is due process. It has recently changed tack to say the SEZs will not be denotified till the Goa government compensates the SEZ promoters. This arrogant and partisan behaviour needs to be tackled at the highest level, but our Chief Minister is keeping mum.

The government’s deliberate inaction is obvious, and isn’t going to fool the people. To avoid further law and order problems, the government needs to look into the land allotments, serve notice on the SEZ promoters, expose the irregularities, cancel the land allotments, and take back the land, legally. That’s the only way out of this mess.

SVM accuses Rahejas of indulging in false accusations

NT NETWORK Posted on 2008-08-21
PANAJI - The SEZ Virodhi Manch has condemned the allegations made against peaceful protesters by the local officials of K Raheja Corporation Pvt Ltd and charged that it was a malicious attempt to tarnish the image of the SEZ Virodhi Manch, which has been agitating peacefully against the fraud of the SEZs in Goa. In a press note issued on Wednesday, the SVM warned the Raheja SEZ officials not to indulge in false accusations and demanded withdrawal of the cases registered with the police failing which the Manch has warned that the proactive, peaceful resistance will be intensified.

Mr Charles Fernandes, the SVM convenor said that the allegations against approximately 150 peaceful protester s who prevented the company workers from continuing work at the SEZ site at Verna on Tuesday were unfounded. He further claimed that 50 per cent of the protestors were ladies, and asserted that no damage was done to company's property or any violence against the labourers and the company staff was committed by the protestors.

It also charged that it was a deliberate attempt by the Rahejas to register false cases against innocent public to force them to withdraw from such peaceful agitations. The SVM also questioned the immediate registration of offence against peaceful protesters and the failure to register an FIR lodged by villagers against the GIDC officials and SEZ promoters till date.

The SVM also questioned how the police registered an offence against the public in a notified SEZ when they do not have jurisdiction in notified SEZs as per the SEZ Act and demanded that the government immediately issue show cause notices to all the promoters of SEZs in Goa, register the FIR filed by People's Movement Against SEZ on October 22, 2007 and set up an inquiry into the scam in the process of approvals forwarded for SEZs and also called on every MLA to walk the talk against SEZs within the deliberations and resolutions in the assembly.

The SVM said that approximately 150 villagers out of which 50 per cent were ladies had gone to protest the resumption of the construction activity in the Raheja SEZ. It alleged that statements made by Raheja officials that the workers present were only minimal maintenance workers was false as could be seen from electronic footage taken and argued that about 50 workers were found working on construction.

Reiterating that absolutely no damage was done to property or violence committed towards labourers and staff present by the protesters as witnessed by two vehicles of Vema Outpost Poilce personnel present, it warned that the people were running out of patience and were being further provoked by such complaints.
http://www.navhindtimes.com/story.php?story=2008082120

Activists storm Verna SEZ site, stop work

HERALD REPORTER
VASCO, AUG 19 – Activists of the SEZ Virodhi Manch (SVM) from Verna and Loutolim stormed into a SEZ construction site at Verna on Tuesday and stopped work there.
Goa Bachao Abhiyan Activist Pravin Sabnis, SEZ Virodhi Manch convenor Charles Fernandes, Peter Gama and Fr Eremito Rebello barged into the SEZ site, after they were informed about the ongoing work at the site. The project is being developed at Phase IV of Verna Industrial Estate, after getting respite from the High Court to resume work.

As the activists were trying to stop the work, labourers were seen running to take cover against the activists. Some activists even rushed to the makeshift office and flushed out personnel seated there. They warned them not to start any work at the site. Labourers who wanted to leave the site were stopped till the police could arrive at the site. The panic-stricken labourers claimed that they had started the work a week ago and had been brought by a contractor from Mumbai.

Addressing the activists, Pravin Sabnis of GBA said that on December 8, 2007 Chief Minister Digambar Kamat had announced that all ongoing work at the SEZs would be stopped.
“Subsequently the work at Keri and Verna SEZs were stopped and later in January, the chief minister had announced that all SEZs would be scrapped. But nothing has been done and the government is fooling the people,” he added. Commenting on the compensation to the SEZ promoters, Sabnis claimed that the SEZ promoters should instead compensate the people for destroying flora and fauna in the area.

Fr Rebello lambasted the lethargic attitude of the government towards SEZ promoters.
“The government is quick to take action when the common man illegally undertakes minor constructions. Why is it reluctant to stop this huge illegal construction,” asked Fr Rebello.
It may be recalled that SVM activities had earlier obstructed 200 workers on December 10, 2007, bringing the work to a halt.

Meanwhile, Ashok Keni, former Navy commander and security chief at the site filed a police complaint, claiming that around 70 people had trespassed into his office and had assaulted him and his colleagues, besides damaging property. Maina-Courtorim PI Dharmesh Angle said that a case against 70 unknown persons have been registered under Sections 143 (forming unlawful assembly), 323 (assault), 427 (damaging property), 447 (trespass) and 506 (2) r/w 149 IPC.
http://www.oheraldo .in/pagedetails. asp?nid=8631&cid=10

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

destruction by Raheja continues

Dated: 19/08//200/8
Press Release
The SEZ Virodhi Manch expresses disgust at the double standards of the government of making empty statements/promises with regard to the scrapping of SEZs from Goa. At the ground level work and full scale destruction activity is taking place by the Raheja SEZ at Verna. When the Government withdrew its Stop Work Notices issued to SEZ Promoters from the High Court on procedural lapses, it promised the citizens of Goa that fresh Show Cause Notices in accordance with the law would be issued to the Promoters of SEZs in Goa. Till date, there has not been a single Show Cause Notice issued to the promoters, on the contrary, the Government has allowed the promoters to re-start work by its inactions.
Despite several representations to de-notify the Special Economic Policy from the State, the Government of Goa has not done so, which exposes their malicious intentions.
It may be recollected that when the villagers entered the Meditab SEZ at Keri and the Raheja SEZ at Verna on 7 and 10 December 2007, the print and electronic media was witness to statements made by their liaison-officers talking of "verbal permissions given by the GIDC”.
Today, 19th August, 2008 the people from various villages after learning that the works at the Raheja SEZ at Verna had been restarted entered the site in large numbers and forced the workers to stop work and leave the site. It is deploring that time and again the people are compelled to forget their daily chores to fight for their rights while the Government repeatedly fools the people. Repeatedly it is the people who have to enter the SEZ premises and force the SEZ promoters to stop work. Till date the people have not resorted to any violence but they also should not be taken for granted. The people have made their intentions clear that they will not allow the works to go on at any costs and warn the Govt. that it will be solely responsible for the outburst of any violence in future. The SVM is surprised that now many MLA’s belonging to the ruling and opposition parties who used to sing anti-SEZ tunes have conveniently forgotten the same. The SVM now demands from all those anti SEZ MLA.’s to bring up the issue before the Assembly session in progress and demand passing of a bill scrapping the SEZ policy existing in the State. This will prove their sincerity over the issue.
The SVM calls for immediate actions by the Government that immediate Show Cause Notices be issued procedurally to all the promoters of SEZs in Goa, register the FIR filed by villagers People’s Movement Against SEZ on 22nd October 2007 instead of criminal dilly-dallying by the Goa Police and set up CBI inquiry into the scam in the process of approvals forwarded for SEZs.
The SVM warns the Government and the SEZ promoters to desist from playing with the sentiments of Goans. The peaceful protests of the SVM should not be construed as a sign of weakness. The government should not provoke the peaceful people of Goa.
Charles Fernandes
Convenor
SEZ Virodhi Manch

Friday, August 8, 2008

SEZs must Quit Goa

The SEZ Virodhi Manch
invites you to join the solidarity
at Azad Maidan, Panaji
on 9 August 2008 (Quit India Day)
from 10am-11.30 am

Kindly assemble before 9.30 am
with your banners & placards
Let's say in one voice
QUIT GOA
to the fraud of SEZs
QUIT GOA
to Irresponsible anti-people "Development"
QUIT GOA
to attacks on our land, lives and livelihoods

Sunday, July 20, 2008

GIDC needs time to reply

Hearing adjourned as GIDC seeks time to file reply
HERALD REPORTERPANJIM, JULY 18 –
Hearing on the writ pleas filed by the villagers of Sancoale, Verna and Keri-Ponda was today adjourned till September 8 as the Goa Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC) sought time to file its reply.
The villagers through three different writ petitions, filed before the Bombay High Court at Goa last week, have challenged the land allotment to developers of the Special Economic Zone (SEZs) in the State. The allotment of land has been challenged on grounds that GIDC transferred the land in gross violation of law and transactions were executed in “most high-handed manner”.
Allotment was made without putting up an advertisement or calling for tenders or auctioning the land to the highest bidder, the petitioners alleged. Hearing on petitions of Meditab Specialities Pvt Ltd, and K Raheja Corporation Pvt Ltd, was also adjourned for September 8. Both SEZ developers are before the Court over show cause notices issued by GIDC threatening to revoke lease deeds and take back the land by refunding the premium, interest and leased rent paid.
The High Court had granted temporary relief in the form of status quo on the show cause notices issued to K Raheja Corporation Pvt Ltd. K Raheja Corporation Pvt Ltd, was the first to move Court with respect to show cause notice issued by GIDC.

Saturday, July 19, 2008

Knowledge SEZs ?

  • EPZ, STZ, IT Park, Biotech Park, Food Park and now KNOWLEDGE SEZs???
    SEZs by any name are a mega land grab for real estate with the Government clearing the title of the land.
  • SEZs are “a country within a country” (Govt definition) and outside the purview of the laws of the land.
  • Even the argument of economic growth is a colossal con as the SEZs need to show only net profit.
  • After all what has happened with the fraud of SEZs in Goa, anyone who supports SEZs in Goa is an obvious partner in crime against our motherland.

    In response to the following news:
    Willy, Khalap, Nitin favour knowledge cities
    NT NETWORK
    PANAJI The deputy chairman of the State Planning Board, Dr Wilfred de Sousa on Friday welcomed the recommendation of a sub-committee on knowledge economy constituted by the State Planning Board under the chairmanship of the noted Goan economist, Dr V A Pai Panandiker as regards setting up of ˜knowledge cities or knowledge industrial parks in Goa.
    The sub-committee, in its report, had used the terminology educational SEZs or knowledge SEZs for the knowledge cities or knowledge industrial parks.
    Speaking to The Navhind Times, Dr de Sousa said that such educational centres of excellence, providing advanced education, would definitely help the local students, a great deal. It a very good idea, he added.
    The former deputy chairman of the State Planning Board, Mr Ramakant Khalap, told this daily that although the report of the Dr Panandiker sub-committee came to him during his tenure as the Planning Board deputy, no discussion took place on the same due to various factors including short term of the then government.
    In fact, the recommendation of the report to set up educational SEZs or knowledge SEZs in Goa is very good, except the terminology used, now that the special economic zones have attracted controversy around them, Mr Khalap said, adding, the welcome concept suggested in the report should have stuck to the terminology knowledge cities or knowledge industrial parks, instead of the SEZs.
    It is a fact that the state is missing on so many things as far as education is concerned, including intellect, content and to some extent specialised faculty, Mr Khalap said, adding, The modern-day education, especially in advanced fields of science, is virtually galloping, while we have no facilities to train our local students in them.
    However, the government should first approach the people and discuss with them modalities of setting up such educational cities, followed by debates in the House over this issue, as suggested in the report, he observed.
    The former Planning Board deputy also noted that knowledge cities or knowledge industrial parks should not degenerate into real estate business, or commercial ventures like educational malls, which demand high academic fees, exorbitant capitation fees or donations.
    The government should strictly supervise such projects, he suggested.
    Welcoming the concept of knowledge cities or knowledge industrial parks, the Goa Chamber of Commerce and Industry chairman, Mr Nitin Kuncolienkar said the terms educational SEZ or knowledge SEZ are seen in bad taste due to the mishandling of the entire SEZ issue by the government.
    Stating that the government should now go for an alternate model for the development of Goa, the GCCI chief said that non-polluting knowledge industry is the best option as it can not only develop skill-based industry but also train the locals in advanced education, which would be very helpful in generation of jobs.
    Or else, a situation wherein the state will face an economic disaster in next 5 years, is inevitable, he added, pointing out that the trends, in this direction, have started showing.

Sunday, July 13, 2008

NDTV exposes Goa SEZ fraud

Goa SEZ papers indicate rule violations
Ketki Angre
Sunday, July 13, 2008 (Goa)

The Goa government recently scrapped seven SEZs that were coming up in the state, reportedly because of violations in the way they were allotted in the first place.

The government says that this was in response to large scale public protests, fearing the SEZ's would burden the infrastructure without generating jobs for locals.

But Documents obtained by activists using the Right to Information found that there were violations in how these SEZ's were allotted.

The SEZs were cleared by the previous Goa Government under CM Pratapsinh Rane, which sanctioned the SEZs in two separate meetings.In one batch , nearly 400 acres of land were given to 4 SEZs in Verna in South Goa. The Ashok Piramal Group's Planetview Mercantile Private Ltd, Piramal's Inox Mercantile Private Ltd, K Raheja Corporation Limited, one of Mumbai's biggest construction firms and K Raheja's Paradigm Logistics And Solutions Private Ltd.

But documents obtained under RTI from the Goa Industrial Development Corporation and the directorate of industries find that all four SEZ applications were technically incomplete.

The company seal on documents were missing and the crucial bank finance guarantee was missing. The Goa government meeting in which the four SEZs were sanctioned didn't even have the mandatory quorum, which makes all its decisions null and void.

A glaring flaw in the document was that Planetview Mercantile Private Limited, a subsidiary of the Ashok Piramal Group, did not even exist when it was sanctioned nearly 25 acres of land. The company was formed a week after its request for land was cleared.Clearances which experts agree are suspect. Suhail Nathani, partner, Economic Laws Practice said, ''A meeting held without quorum is not valid. And an application made by a non existant company/ entity is just what it suggests .. That it is not a valid application because the body corporate, which is the applicant did not exist on that particular day.''

But the Goa Industrial Development Corporation insists the clearances were in order. Nitin Kunkolienkar, director, Goa Industrial Development Corporation said, ''There's absolute quorum, it was perfectly right, no one has understood the provision of the Act. The quorum requirement is four people, so the entire quorum was present at the meeting and the meeting was totally legal. It is beyond doubt. Whether the company existed or not is not our lookout. We follow the meeting agenda.''

This in spite of the Act stating that the Director of Industries is needed to reach quorum when only four members are present.

When contacted, the Piramal group in an emailed statement said: ''When the application was made, the company was under formation. It is clearly mentioned accordingly in the application form. As a result, the application form did not have its company seal. As regards the bank finance guarantee, there was no requirement in the application form. Moreover, the land allotment was done based on the skills and credentials of Peninsula and not depending upon the SPV in isolation.''

Interestingly, nowhere in the application form is it mentioned that Planetview Mercantile is a Piramal subsidiary or was under formation and the GIDC website clearly says that a letter from the bank/financial institution agreeing to finance the project is needed to be eligible.

In spite of repeated attempts the K Raheja Corporation did not respond to these allegations.

Family connections

In allocation of another 300 acres of land in Ponda in central Goa, there is evidence of further violations. Cipla's subsidiary, Meditab Specialities Private Limited, which was given an SEZ here didn't even make a formal application for an SEZ.

Only on the basis of a request letter it was sanctioned nearly 300 acres for a pharmaceutical SEZ on the direction of the then Industries Minister. The law does say that the corporation is bound to follow directives from the government but this is only in the area of policy directives.

The corporation claims this means all government directives need to be followed. Nitin Kunkolienkar, director, Goa Industrial Development Corporation said, ''You see particular Cipla case, it was referred by the govt. and including the CM's office, industries' minister's office and then the CS has referred it. The Goa-IDC was asked to process that.''

Experts says whatever the directives from the state, the corporation should also have followed the official procedures. This includes insisting on a formal application. ''There is a procedure that needs to be followed and there is no provision in the law to compromise the process. While the decision maybe dictated, that's something the act does provide, but certainly there is no provision for doing away with the process, so to my mind they would have to follow process,'' Nathani said.

But when contacted, Pharma giant CIPLA has said procedures were followed and the allegations are baseless.

Of the seven SEZs that the Goa government subsequently scrapped, three were promoted by the Piramal Group the signatory on its documents is Amish Yoddha.

But interestingly Yoddha is the son-in-law of AV Palekar the Managing Director of the Goa Industrial Development Corporation. The Goa government body that allocated the lands, a deal which some say raises serious questions of conflict of interest.

But the Piramal Group in its statement says: ''There is no conflict of interest. Amish Yoddha was authorised to represent the company vide a valid Board Resolution. The land allotment took place much before his wedding with daughter of Mr A V Palekar and there is no connection between the two events. The Deed of lease was executed on August 2, 2006 whereas the wedding took place on January 29, 2008.''

Former chief minister Pratapsinh Rane in whose tenure the SEZs were santioned refused to comment, saying the matter of SEZ clearances was now in court

Goa's chief minister Digambar Kamat who subsequently scrapped the SEZs said his government stand was clear - it did not want SEZs anymore.

But the question on how they were allotted will still stand.

http://www.ndtv.com/convergence/ndtv/story.aspx?id=NEWEN20080056846&ch=7

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Villagers challenge SEZ land allotment

HERALD REPORTER
PANJIM, JULY 9 — Villagers of Sancoale, Verna, and Keri-Ponda through three separate writ petitions filed before the Bombay High Court at Goa, have challenged the allotment of land to SEZ developers in the State.
The villagers have challenged the allotment of land on grounds that Goa Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC) has transferred the land in gross violation of law and in most high-handed manner. Allotment was made even without putting up an advertisement or calling for tenders or auctioning the land to the highest bidder, the petitioners alleged.
Furthermore, the GIDC is accused of making the allotments of land in total violation of the provisions of the Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 as well as State’s own SEZ policy.
The petitioners have challenged the land allotment made to M/s Peninsular Pharma Research Center Pvt Ltd, which has acquired land to set up SEZ in Sancoale, M/s Meditab Specialities Pvt Ltd in Keri Ponda and M/s K Raheja Corporation Pvt Ltd, M/s Paradigm Logistic and Distribution Pvt Ltd, M/s Inox Mercantile Co Pvt Ltd, M/s Planet View Mercantile Pvt Ltd, Maxgrow Finlease Pvt Ltd, who want to have SEZs in Verna Industrial Estate.
They have prayed for an order quashing the land allotment in the industrial estate and revert it to the original owners from whom the land was acquired.
Petitioners also want that the entire process of allotment enquired into by an independent body like the CBI or have a commission of inquiry headed either by a High Court or a Supreme Court Judge to look into the irregularities in the entire allotment procedure including the possibility of irregular graft.
The petitions have been posted for hearing on July 18.

Goa villagers petition against SEZ land allotment
http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/blnus/03101220.htm
PANAJI: Goa villagers have approached the Goa bench of Bombay High Courtappealing against the Special Economic Zones(SEZs) land allotment byState government-run Goa Industrial Development Corporation(GIDC). The villagers, in their petition before the court, have termed the landallotment as "fraudulent". The villagers from Keri, Sancoale and Verna, have filed a petitionchallenging GIDC's decision to allot land to these SEZs in theirvillages, on 95-year-lease basis. The petition mostly concerns three notified SEZs -- Meditab SpecialitiesPvt Ltd, K Raheja and Peninsula Pharma Research Pvt Ltd. The petition has also questioned land allotment in seven SEZs includingthese three. The villagers have complained that the land was allottedwithout involving public in the land allotment process. "In some case, the land was allotted as quick as within seven days ofthe application," Colin Gonsalves, a lawyer representing the villagers,said. GIDC which faced severe criticism for allotment of the land, has alreadyissued showcause notice to all the seven SEZ promoters. GIDC officials said that they have decided to revoke the land allotmentacting on the directives of the government. "We have issued showcause notices and final step to revoke the land willbe decided after the meet by board of directors" a senior official said.Also, SEZ issue is a hotly debated issue in the state with DigamerKamat-led government taking anti-SEZ stand bowing to the pressures ofthe masses. - PTI